You’re sipping a $90 Pinot Noir that tastes like cherry, moss, and something that feels like…sincerity. The label says “biodynamic,” and suddenly you’re picturing a cloaked winemaker burying a cow horn full of manure under a waxing moon.
Welcome to the battleground of modern wine.
Biodynamic viticulture is either:
And like any good debate, both can be true.
Stakeholders
Biodynamic Advocates
Organic Purists
Conventional Scientists
Marketing Departments
Demeter certification is described as the Vatican of biodynamic wine, which blesses the faithful and frustrates skeptics. Austria has its own certification called Biodyvin.
Biodynamic viticulture is based on the holistic farming concepts developed by Rudolf Steiner in the 1920s. Interestingly, biodynamic agriculture predates the organic farming movement by approximately twenty years. Organic viticulture provides the foundation for biodynamic practices, with biodynamic viticulture meeting or exceeding the standards required for organic certification and compliance.
At its core, biodynamics is organic farming on steroids, layered with lunar cycles, esoteric rituals, and a deep belief that the vineyard is a living being. It emphasizes the interconnectedness of soil, plants, livestock, and humans in a self-sustaining ecosystem.
In biodynamic viticulture, the vine is at the center, with its health and growth influenced by cosmic energies and holistic vineyard management practices. Wine growers are responsible for implementing these holistic practices, ensuring the vineyard operates in harmony with nature. Biodynamic vineyards often implement species-rich crop rotation and livestock farming as part of their holistic farming approach. Improving soil health and fostering biodiversity are fundamental aspects of biodynamic practices in viticulture.
The key differences between organic and biodynamic viticulture lie in their philosophies, practices, and certification standards. The comparison:
Both organic and biodynamic avoid synthetic inputs and can produce organic wine, but biodynamic wine is considered a distinct category due to its additional spiritual and holistic practices.
If biodynamics were a religion, these would be the sacraments:
Are they scientifically proven? No. Are they symbolically powerful and empirically valued by some of the world’s top winemakers? Absolutely.
This is where ritual meets regenerative farming. Think less “evidence-based practice” and more “ancestral wisdom.”
If you thought winemaking was just about sunshine and soil, think again—biodynamic farming brings the cosmos into the vineyard. At the heart of biodynamic viticulture is the biodynamic calendar, a tool that guides biodynamic farmers and winemakers through every step of the growing season. This isn’t your average planner; it’s a celestial roadmap, dividing the year into Root, Fruit, Flower, and Leaf Days, each aligned with the lunar cycle and the positions of celestial bodies.
Here’s how it works:
Biodynamic wineries, from the rolling hills of Sonoma County to the legendary vineyards of Burgundy, use this calendar to schedule everything from planting and pruning to harvesting. The idea is that aligning vineyard activities with these cosmic rhythms enhances the vines' vitality and the quality of the wine.
For example, a biodynamic winemaker might choose to harvest grapes on a Fruit Day, believing it will maximize the fruit’s flavour and aroma. Pruning and planting are also timed to harness the earth’s natural energies, as interpreted through the calendar. This approach is centred on working in harmony with nature and the universe, aiming to produce organic and biodynamic wines that are not only sustainable but also deeply expressive of their unique terroir.
Whether you see it as ancient wisdom or just another layer of vineyard mystique, the biodynamic calendar is a cornerstone of biodynamic practices. It’s a daily reminder for biodynamic farmers and winemakers that their work is part of a much larger dance—one that includes the earth, the moon, and the stars, all in pursuit of wines that truly reflect their place of origin.
Biodynamic wines have cachet. They tap into the “natural” zeitgeist and sell like moral superiority in a bottle. Advocates highlight the benefits of biodynamic practices, such as sustainability, regional expression, and environmental stewardship, as key reasons for their appeal. Despite some skepticism about the spiritual aspects of biodynamics, there is a growing trend toward sustainably produced wines in the market.
But when you strip away the branding:
Many top-tier estates (Domaine de la Romanée-Conti, Nikolaihof, Coulee de Serrant) are biodynamic. But is it causation or correlation? That’s where science shrugs.
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: There is little rigorous, peer-reviewed evidence that biodynamics outperforms organics. Most studies show no significant difference in yield, microbial life, or disease resistance beyond what organic already provides.
But here's what can’t be dismissed:
So the real force behind biodynamics might be intention.
To slap “biodynamic” on your label, you need certification. Biodynamic certifications are the formal recognition that a vineyard or winery adheres to strict biodynamic standards and practices. Being certified biodynamic means that the winery has met rigorous quality benchmarks and has been officially validated by an authoritative certifying body, which adds credibility and trust for consumers. Demeter International is the leading global organization overseeing biodynamic certifications, setting consistent international standards and ensuring compliance worldwide.
The process of obtaining biodynamic certification involves detailed inspections, documentation, and adherence to specific biodynamic preparations and holistic agricultural practices. Demeter is one of the two primary organizations that provide biodynamic certification. Biodynamic wineries undergo annual inspections by independent control bodies to ensure compliance with practices. And Demeter makes you jump through hoops:
Demeter critics say it’s dogmatic and unverifiable. Supporters call it rigorous and necessary.
Either way, Demeter is the gatekeeper of legitimacy, and its seal sells bottles. Both Demeter and Respekt-BIODYN operate under similar biodynamic regulations, but each has specific codes of practice for its members.
Step into a biodynamic wine cellar, and you’ll find a philosophy that’s as much about what’s left out as what’s put in. Natural winemaking is the essence of biodynamic wine production, emphasizing a hands-off approach that allows the grapes and the land to speak for themselves. For many biodynamic winemakers, the goal is simple: create wines that are a pure reflection of their vineyard, their terroir, and the rhythms of nature.
This process begins in the vineyard, where biodynamic farmers utilize natural materials, such as cow horns filled with manure, to enrich the soil and promote a thriving ecosystem. Forget synthetic pesticides and fertilizers—biodynamic methods rely on compost, herbal teas, and beneficial insects for disease management, keeping the vines healthy without disrupting the balance of nature. The result is a vineyard that’s alive with microbial activity, supporting the health of the grapes and the land.
In the winery, the philosophy continues. Biodynamic winemaking involves minimal intervention, utilizing native yeasts for fermentation, minimal to no added sulphites, and avoiding fining or filtering. The idea is to let the wine develop naturally, capturing the unique character of each vintage and vineyard. Whether it’s a rich, earthy red or a vibrant, mineral-driven white, biodynamic wines are celebrated for their depth, complexity, and sense of place.
Demeter-certified wineries and other biodynamic producers around the world are proving that this approach isn’t just about tradition. It’s about quality. By emphasizing natural winemaking and sustainable viticulture, they’re crafting wines that are as rich in story as they are in flavour. For wine lovers, choosing biodynamic wines means supporting a world where farming, winemaking, and nature are inextricably linked—one glass at a time.
Step into a biodynamic wine cellar, and you’ll find a philosophy that’s as much about what’s left out as what’s put in. Natural winemaking is the essence of biodynamic wine production, emphasizing a hands-off approach that allows the grapes and the land to speak for themselves. For many biodynamic winemakers, the goal is simple: create wines that are a pure reflection of their vineyard, their terroir, and the rhythms of nature.
This process begins in the vineyard, where biodynamic farmers utilize natural materials, such as cow horns filled with manure, to enrich the soil and promote a thriving ecosystem. Forget synthetic pesticides and fertilizers—biodynamic methods rely on compost, herbal teas, and beneficial insects for disease management, keeping the vines healthy without disrupting the balance of nature. The result is a vineyard that’s alive with microbial activity, supporting the health of the grapes and the land.
In the winery, the philosophy continues. Biodynamic winemaking involves minimal intervention, utilizing native yeasts for fermentation, minimal to no added sulphites, and avoiding fining or filtering. The idea is to let the wine develop naturally, capturing the unique character of each vintage and vineyard. Whether it’s a rich, earthy red or a vibrant, mineral-driven white, biodynamic wines are celebrated for their depth, complexity, and sense of place.
Demeter-certified wineries and other biodynamic producers around the world are proving that this approach isn’t just about tradition. It’s about quality. By emphasizing natural winemaking and sustainable viticulture, they’re crafting wines that are as rich in story as they are in flavour. For wine lovers, choosing biodynamic wines means supporting a world where farming, winemaking, and nature are inextricably linked—one glass at a time.
After these leading estates, many other wineries worldwide have adopted biodynamic practices, demonstrating the widespread appeal and success of this approach. France remains a significant leader, with regions such as Alsace and Burgundy at the forefront of biodynamic wine production, particularly for aromatic and high-quality white wines. Italy is also seeing rapid growth in biodynamic viticulture, particularly in Tuscany and Sicily, further integrating these practices into its rich winemaking heritage.
Biodynamics is a belief system dressed in agricultural garb.
It may not be science, but it inspires scientific behaviour: curiosity, observation, adaptation.
You don’t have to believe in moon phases or cow horns to benefit from biodynamic principles.
You don't need to believe that the moon and the sun influence the tides.
Maybe the magic isn’t in the moon.
It’s in the mindset.
Adopting biodynamic practices requires a commitment to hands-on management in viticulture, often resulting in lower yields.
Think about it this way:
If You Believe… → Then Biodynamics Is…
Role → Biodynamics Is Worth It If…
You don’t need to be a biodynamic evangelist—or a cynic. Just taste more. Ask questions. Visit vineyards. Watch a cow horn burial. Then decide what you believe.
Because in wine, like in life, sometimes the weirdest path leads to the most interesting glass.
Copyright © 2024 Vinerra Corp.
